Truth or dare. That game has the potential for serious mischief. A classic for sleepovers, even college sleepovers. Or at least group of childhood friends who all went to the same local college sleepovers. It started relatively innocently. For twenty minutes it was the classic game anyone would recognize. But slowly we had upped the stakes. We were playing for the grand prize, someone being our personal slave. Laura suggested the rules, which we all agreed to. If you lied on a truth, you would be the slave to the one who you offered truth to. If you chose dare and didn't do it, everybody would have to do it. The person who initially refused could then do it to avoid the consequences. Anybody who didn't do it would be the slave to everybody who did. Nobody could quit until someone was a slave. There were seven of us. Laura, Caitlin, Alyssa, Tessa, Georgia, Violet, and me, Samantha. We had been at it for ten minutes already, and it was Caitlin's turn.
"Alyssa, truth or dare." Caitlin asked.
"Truth." Alyssa replied.
"Are you a virgin?" Caitlin asked.
"Yes." Alyssa answered. "Truth or dare Caitlin?"
"Truth." Caitlin returned.
"Are you a virgin?" Alyssa asked.
"Yes." Caitlin replied. "Tessa, truth or dare?" She asked.
"Dare." Tessa replied.
"I dare you to take off all your clothes." Caitlin said.
"No." Tessa answered.
"No?" Caitlin asked, smiling.
"I'm not doing it." Tessa said.
Caitlin started removing her own shirt. Laura got the hint first and started taking her clothes off too. The rest of us quickly followed. Georgia looked at the still clothed Tessa.
"How about it Tessa, are you ready to be a slave?" Georgia asked Tessa.
Tessa sighed, then stripped down.
"Tessa refused at first, so it's still Caitlin's turn." Laura said.
"That's right." Caitlin said. She looked at me. "Samantha, truth or dare?" She asked.
I was feeling a little brave. "Dare." I said.
"I dare you to check to see if Alyssa is a virgin." She said.
"Hey!" Alyssa said.
"You said you were a virgin. If you want to admit that you were lying then she wouldn't have to check." Laura said.
"We'll hold you down if necessary." Caitlin added.
"Fine." Alyssa said.
I walked over to Alyssa. She was sitting on the bed. She spread her legs apart and I got a good look at her vagina. I had only ever seen mine up close before. Hers was puffy, completely enveloped by the outer lips. She had a little hair on it, but it was soft and thin. A little lighter in color than the brown hair on her head. I knelt down and examined it. She brought one hand down and parted her own lips. I was at first careful not to touch her, but I couldn't see well enough and had to part it a little more myself. I looked until I saw her intact hymen.
"She's a virgin." I said, wondering if there was a reason Caitlin would think she would lie. "My turn."
I moved back to the chair I had been sitting on, then smiled at Caitlin.
"Alyssa, truth or dare?" I asked.
"Dare." Alyssa replied boldly.
"I dare you to check to see if Caitlin is a virgin." I said.
"I'll get you for this one." Caitlin vowed.
Alyssa smiled and got up, walking over to Caitlin. She knelt down and checked her quickly.
"She's a virgin." Alyssa said.
Alyssa looked at Tessa. "Tessa, truth or dare?"
"Truth." Tessa answered.
"Of course! She's afraid!" Georgia said.
"Fine, dare!" Tessa huffed.
"That wasn't nice, Georgia." I said.
Alyssa smiled. "I dare you to check the virginity of everyone here."
"That's not really fair, you only had to do one." Violet said.
"Well if she turns it down I'll do it." Alyssa said. "If she doesn't believe me she's free to turn it down, but once they're checked she can't really check them again."
"Nobody is stopping her, it's not like it would just disappear." Laura commented. "Actually since Alyssa said everyone, that means Tessa would have to check her too."
Tessa sighed and got up. She went around checking every girl, and verify they were virgins, even the ones whom were already checked before.
"You like touching me there, don't you?" Georgia taunted her as she probed.
Tessa blushed and finished her task. Everybody was verified as a virgin. She sat down.
"You all are such prudes!" I said.
"You're a virgin too, miss prude." Caitlin said.
"I once gave a guy a blowjob." I said.
"That means you lied!" Violet said.
"Technically she is an actual virgin, at least in the way we were checking for." Laura said.
"And I was only checked. Nobody actually asked me." I said.
"Who cares? It's my turn." Tessa said.
"Wait a minute, what about you?" Alyssa asked.
"I'm a virgin." Tessa said.
"I didn't see you check." Alyssa stated.
Tessa walked in front of Alyssa, bent over slightly backwards and spread her lips. Tessa's vagina look more like mine than Alyssa's. Perpetually slightly open, with her clitoris peeking out a bit. Her pubic hair went all around like mine, but it was much thinner. It was much more curly than the straight hair on her head, but was the same dark color.
"See? Virgin. Now that you're satisfied, can I finally have my turn?" Tessa asked.
"Sorry." Alyssa said.
Tessa looked at me.
"Yea, sorry." I said.
"Good. Georgia, truth or dare?" Tessa asked.
"Dare." Georgia responded.
"I dare you to lick Alyssa's pussy." Tessa said, smirking.
"I'm not gay." Georgia said.
"I didn't say you were. I dared you to lick a pussy. Are you refusing?" Tessa asked.
"No." Georgia said.
She got up and walk over to Alyssa. Alyssa looked away, but spread her legs apart. Georgia pulled her wavy red hair out of her face and then put her head between Alyssa's spread legs. Her head bobbed up and down 3 times, and I saw Alyssa grab the blanket on the bed that she was sitting on. Georgia then stood back up.
"My turn. I dare you to masturbate in front of us all." Georgia said to Tessa.
"Fine." Tessa said, and then started rubbing her clit with her middle finger. We watched as she masturbated. Her vagina opened even more as she rubbed herself, revealing her inner folds, with slight beads of moisture on them. Things had certainly accelerated rapidly. I wondered if I would be able to make myself do these dares. I looked around the room. This probably was close to the line for all the girls. If I could hold out, I could probably have a slave. I turned back to Tessa. She had seemed a little tense when she first started, but quickly got over it as she rubbed herself. Soon she shivered as she orgasmed.
"It looks like you really enjoyed that." Violet said to Tessa.
"Violet, since you seem to like looking at that kind of thing, I dare you masturbate Georgia." Tessa said.
"That's not right, Georgia wasn't dared." Violet said.
"Are you refusing, Violet?" Georgia asked.
Violet walked over to Georgia and sat down next to her. Violet snaked her hand across Georgia's stomach and between her legs, bringing her fingertips to to just below the vaginal slit, covering Georgia's pussy with her hand. She then curled her middle and ring finger while dragging her hand upwards. She then straightened her fingers and pushed down with her palm. Violet repeated the motion again and again, each time a little faster than before, rubbing Georgia pussy. Very quickly Georgia started moving her hips to Violet's actions. We watched as Violet brought Georgia to climax.
After finishing Georgia off, Violet returned to her seat. She looked around the room.
"Okay, my turn." Violet said.
"Georgia, I dare you to use your tongue on me until I feel good." Violet said.
Georgia smirked but didn't say anything as she stood up and walked over to Violet, who spread her legs wide in invitation. Georgia tossed her hair to the side, then knelt down in front of Violet. She put her face into Violet's pussy. Her head began bobbing, and Violet closed her eyes and leaned back.
"Look at that lesbo go!" Caitlin said, watching the show.
Georgia tensed up, but didn't stop. She grabbed Violet's thighs and held them tight as her head moved faster. Violet started moaning, and Georgia picked up the pace. It was mear moments before Violet started shuddering in climax.
"My turn" Georgia said, lifting her wet face out of Violet's snatch.
"Caitlin, I dare you to suck on Laura's tits while masturbating both her and yourself." Georgia said.
Caitlin stood up and moved over to Laura, instantly putting her lips around her nipple. She sucked for a little bit, then crawled on top of Laura. With her hand she encouraged Laura to lay on her side. Caitlin sucked on Laura's nipple while she slid one hand between Laura's legs and one between her own. I saw her elbows moving as she worked both of their pussies. As Caitlin worked, Laura started breathing more rapidly. It looked dirty, but arousing. We all watched without speaking.
"Oh god... Oh!" Laura suddenly moaned as her legs straightened. Caitlin continued sucking on Laura's nipple for a minute while rubbing herself, then let the nipple fall out of her mouth as she sucked a sharp breath in, achieving climax herself.
"Was that good?" Caitlin asked
"That's good." Georgia answered.
"Very good." Laura added, a little out of breath.
Caitlin smiled. "Good, my turn." Caitlin said. "Samantha."
"Yes." I responded.
"I dare you to..." she said, then pausing.
"Yes?" I asked.
"Nothing's off limits as long as I'm willing to do it, right?" Caitlin asked Laura.
"That's correct." Laura responded.
"And what we would have to do doesn't change, right? Like if I said your toothbrush, it would be Samantha's toothbrush for me too, right?" Caitlin continued.
"That's right." Laura answered.
I felt fear in my stomach. This wasn't going to be good, I was sure.
"Samantha, I dare you to lose your virginity your dad." Caitlin said.
"Absolutely not!" I answered
"That isn't funny Caitlin." Violet said.
"I'm not kidding. I'll do it, and if anyone doesn't want to, they can be my slave. Those are the rules are they not?" Caitlin said.
"Those are indeed the rules." Laura answered.
"He's not going to want to do that." Georgia said.
"With all of us here, I'm sure we can hold him down and do it to him." Caitlin answered. "That's what we were going to do earlier to Alyssa."
"Yep, that's right." Laura said.
"I don't think Caitlin will follow through." I said.
"You'll make a good slave." Caitlin said.
"I doubt she'll do it." Violet said.
"If any of us do it, those that won't are the slaves to those of us who do." Laura said. "We just have to break our hymen on his penis, right?" She asked Caitlin.
"That's right. You just have to lose your virginity." Caitlin answered. "So how about it Samantha?" She asked.
"No." I answered.
"Well, I guess I'll just have to do it." Caitlin said. "Le's all go and get to it."
"This isn't funny. We should stop playing." I said.
"I could agree to that, if you agree to be my slave." Caitlin said.
"You aren't going to do it." I said confidently.
"Watch me." She said.
She started walking to the living room. We all followed her. My dad had fallen asleep on the couch.
"Caitlin, are you sure you want to do this? You can still back out." Laura whispered.
"If you don't want to go through with the dare, I have some clothes you can wash." Caitlin whispered back.
"Okay then. Violet, you will hold his left arm. Georgia, you will hold his right arm. Alyssa, you will hold his left leg. Tessa, you'll hold his right leg. I will get his pants off. Samantha, you will help where you can. When Caitlin is done, she will switch with me, then when I am done, I'll switch with anyone else who wants to. Ready?" Laura asked.
"Ready." Caitlin answered.
We went out and quickly followed Laura's plan. I watched helpless as they moved to pin my dad. He started stirring as Laura took his pants off.
"What are you doing?" My dad groggily asked as Caitlin climbed on top of him.
"She is losing her virginity to you." Laura answered my dad.
"You can't do this, its not right!" he protested, struggling against the four girls holding him down.
"Relax, it will be over soon." Laura said.
I watched as Caitlin grabbed my dad's cock, which had grown rapidly from being surrounded by young naked girls. He stopped moving and closed his eyes tightly. Caitlin guided his cock to her virgin opening. She sat down on his shaft, releasing a sharp breath as her hymen was torn asunder.
"This isn't so bad." Caitlin said, gently rocking up and down on his cock a few times before pulling herself off. "Your turn Laura." She said as she switched.
As Laura positioned her vagina above my dad's rock hard cock, I felt a knot grow in my stomach. There was no way out of this. I either had to do it, or be a slave. I watched as my dad's cock, still bloody from Caitlin's virginity, plunged into Laura's pussy. Laura made a grimace of pain as her hymen was completely pierced. As soon as she had it completely in she started to get up.
"I'm next." Tessa said as Laura pulled all the way off.
My dad's eyes were still closed, but he seemed to be enjoying it.
Tessa climbed on my dad. She seemed a little hesitant as she positioned herself. She looked back at me, then at my dad. She then grabbed his cock and guided it into her as she lowered herself on him, giving up her virginity. Tessa rose up, getting off, and Georgia raised her hand, signaling she was next. As soon as Tessa was clear, Georgia climbed up my dad. Georgia spent a moment to position herself, then pushed quickly down, plunging my dad's cock deep inside her quicker than any girl yet. Her mouth opened in pain and she stopped there for a second. My dad gently rocked his hips, pulling a little out and going back into her. She pulled completely off of him, holding her pussy as she climbed down. Alyssa and Violet both moved to be next. Alyssa saw Violet moving, and beckoned for Violet to go next. Violet crawled on top of my dad. She grabbed his penis and positioned my dad's member at the opening of her vagina. She lowered herself a little, then raised up, then lowered herself a little more than last time. She did this a few times, and started biting her lip. I could tell she was stretching her hymen. Then she came down all the way hard, and came up just as quickly, leaving pieces of her torn hymen behind as she got off my dad. Alyssa climbed immediately afterward. She examined my dad's cock for a second, then moved her pussy over it. She positioned my dad's penis and began to slowly lower herself down, I saw her shudder a little as she used gravity to break her hymen. Once the barrier was pierced, my dad flexed a little under her, sliding himself the rest of the way in. She slowly slid her way off of him, her retreating pussy receiving a few parting pumps from my dad's cock.
Alyssa was off and I was the only remaining virgin in the room. They were all looking at me, it was my time to make a decision. Slavery or incest. It was only 6 months of slavery, but then Caitlin would have beaten me. I walked up to my dad and climbed on top of him. I hovered my pussy over his cock. His eyes were still closed. He probably knew this was coming all along and didn't want to know when it happened. I grabbed his bloody cock with my hand. It looked bigger now that I was holding it. I worried that it might not fit as I guided it to the opening of my virgin hole. I pressed a little down on it, holding it in place with my pussy lips while I got my hand out of the way. I started to slowly slide down, but my dad thrust up as his penis felt a new young fresh virgin opening to enter. I felt a burst of fire as he hit my hymen. It felt like hot wax had been dripped on my skin as my hymen was pierced. I felt his cock slip through my tattered hymen and stretch out the walls of my vagina. It inflicted a tight soreness, but also gave a pleasant tickling sensation.
"It's still my turn." Caitlin said, getting real close to me.
She leaned in and whispered in my ear. "I dare you to make him climax inside you."
I looked at her. She probably would too. I was going to one up her. I looked at Laura, as my dad gently rocked inside me. I gestured Laura over, and whispered to her. "I'm going on the record of refusing, but I go first."
"It's allowed." Laura whispered. She then whispered to everyone else.
I began to rock in motion with my dad.
"Okay girls, you need to stop, I'm about to come." he said, his eyes still closed and oblivious to the fact that it was his own daughter's pussy he was currently inside.
"That's the idea." Caitlin said to him.
With that I felt a ripple go down the length of his cock, then a warm bubbling feeling increased the pressure inside of me as my dad filled my virgin pussy with his semen. I slid off my dads cock, then it felt like I was peeing. I reached a hand down to try to hold it in. My hand was almost instantly coated in blood and cum. As I climbed off, Caitlin climbed back on.
"You have to give me time to recover." my dad said. I saw that his penis wasn't as hard as it was when I put it inside me, and was rapidly getting softer.
"How do we make you recover faster?" Laura asked.
"You could massage my dick. That might work." My dad replied.
Caitlin began stroking his cock, which was well lubricated from our virginal offerings. He was hard again very quickly. Caitlin guided his rapidly hardening member into her cunt, and began rocking on top of him. Caitlin started breathing heavy and rocked faster and faster. Then she started twitching on top of him.
"Oh god, I'm climaxing!" Caitlin said as she tensed up and rocked more slowly.
My dad made up for her slowing action by increasing his own thrusting.
"Here it comes..." he said before he tensed up underneath her.
I watched as my dad pumped his load into her cunt, remembering what it felt like just a few minutes before. Caitlin collapsed, breathing deeply on top of my dad for a minute, before pulling herself off.
Caitlin looked at Laura. "Your turn." she said.
Laura look hesitant.
"It's okay, you don't have to." Georgia said.
"It's just that..." Laura began. "Nevermind. I'm ready." She said as she began to climb back on top of my dad.
It took a little bit longer to warm him up, but Laura soon had him hard again, and she buried his cock deep inside her. I watched as my dad forcefully thrust himself in to Laura's tight virgin cunt again and again. She held on to his chest as he bucked beneath her. She collapsed to her elbows as he repeatedly plunged his cock in and out of her depths. She began to breathe heavily, then started panting in tune with his strokes.
"Oh god, god it's so good..." Laura moaned as she was fucked for the first time.
I saw her fingers and toes curl as she let out a long moan. He kept pounding her as if nothing happened.
"It's too much. It tickles too much!" she begged.
"It's okay. It's almost over." Violet told her.
As if Violet presaged it, my dad thrust one more time hard and then he emptied his balls deep into Laura's open receptacle.
Laura sighed. "Help me up violet, my legs have stopped working."
Violet and Alyssa help her off of my dad. Laura sat down on the floor. Alyssa climbed up onto my dad.
"It's my turn now." Alyssa announced.
"Three times is a lot." My dad said. "I don't think I have anymore in me."
"I'll go get you some water." Georgia said. "It might help."
Georgia fetched a glass of water, and put it up to my dad lips. He drank it all down.
His cock started getting semi hard as Alyssa worked on it. It became harder as she attempted to shove the semi erect member into her womanhood. She got it in, then she began to rock on it. At first it deformed a little, but as she worked it, his cock became more and more rigid. Soon it wasn't flexing at all as it plunged inside of her again and again.
"Here it comes..." My dad moaned after a relatively short period of time.
"Oh god it's happening, its filling me up!" Alyssa exclaimed as my dad came inside her.
"It itches when it dries." Caitlin said, scratching her now cum stained pussy.
"It feels squishy inside." Alyssa said from on top my dad.
"It hurts going in." Georgia said.
"But it feels real good once you get used to it." Laura added still on the floor, smiling.
"I guess I'll go next and give it a try." Georgia said.
"I can't, I'm sore." My dad said as Alyssa's pussy let go of his cock.
"That isn't very fair to the rest of us." Georgia said as she climbed on top of my dad. "Come on, do to me what you did to Laura" She added as she rubbed her wet vagina against my dad's overly sexed cock.
I saw my dad's cock twitch.
"You want me to make you cum? Is that it?" My dad demanded of Georgia, opening his eyes and looking at her lustfully. His reaction slightly scared me, I hadn't seen him like that before.
"I want to feel what Laura felt." Georgia answered.
"Let go of my arms and I will give you what you're asking for." My dad said.
"Go ahead." Laura responded.
Everyone let go, and he grabbed Georgia by the waist and rolled over on top of her.
"So you want to feel me cum inside you, do you?" He asked as he ground his pelvis into her.
"Yes please." Georgia panted, audibly becoming more aroused.
"And you want my dick to make you cum? My dick stained with the blood from your friends virginity?" He added.
"Yes." she panted.
"Your wish is granted." My dad said.
He moved his hips backward, then sighed as he slowly slid his hips forward. Georgia grabbed the couch cushion, and I realized my dad had just slid his cock inside her vagina. He held on to her waist as he slowly worked his penis in and out of her virgin hole. Georgia started breathing heavy, and the breaths started becoming moans. He moved his hands off her waist and onto her shoulders, pressing down as he thrust up, and rapidly increasing his pace. She tensed up, and her moans got loud and drawn out. Then my dad's butt clinched, and his motions became less regular as he grunted. Then he relaxed.
"You like my cum inside you?" He asked Georgia.
"God that felt good." Georgia said.
"Who's next?" He asked.
"I'm next." Violet said.
He reached over and grabbed her, flipping her over the arm off the couch so her butt was in the air. He spread her legs apart with one hand, then started rubbing her pussy with it.
"So you want me to fuck you too, Violet?" He said as he rubbed her pussy. "I remember when you first came over here dragging that oversized purple bear. Now you do this? I'll give you something to remember." He said.
He stroked her pussy with his hand while his cock slowly got hard again. She started moaning, and he brought her to climax. He got of behind her and used his hand to guide his penis into her waiting pussy. He began pulling her to him by her hips. Soon she was building up for another orgasm. He began to pull her even faster, and she screamed out in pleasure. He continued to pump her for a little bit, then he pulled her hips close to him, diving as deep as he could as he released his load into her.
"Me last." Tessa said as my dad pulled out.
My dad beckoned her over, and she walked to him. He patted the couch next to him, and she sat down.
He rolled on top of her and began grinding his pelvis against her's. After a few seconds he pulled back and began to stroke his cock. It slowly grew hard in his hand. He started to drag the tip of his cock up and down the crack of her pussy, then slowly inserted just the tip. He pulled back and rubbed her crack again, following up a second time by inserting no more than the tip. He did it a third time, but instead off just inserting the tip he forced his whole length in her at once. She flinched and gave a small cry of pain. He stopped moving for a second, then slowly begin to slide in and out. She started sighing softly, which turned into heavy breathing. He reached a hand down between them, and the muscles on his arm started twitching. I realized he was massaging her pussy as he was humping her with his cock. He turned his head sideways as the worked her and his eyes met mine. He stopped for a heartbeat, but got back on track right away. He looked down my naked form, and his eyes settled on my blood and cum stained pussy. He turned back to Tessa, and focused on working her to climax. Tessa was biting her bottom lip, and I was pretty sure she was trying to hold in all sounds. It seemed to work, as she shuddered in a silent climax. He continued to hump her for a few minutes, before he clenched up and released his load into her. Finished, he pulled out, then stood up.
"Are you all satisfied now?" He asked, annoyance clear in his voice. "Is this done?"
"Yes, that's it." Laura said.
"Good." He said. "Now all of you get to bed, and we're going to forget that this happened."
We went to bed, our game over with no winners, just cum stained pussies to show for it. The next day my dad pretended like nothing had happened, although he wouldn't meet any of our eyes like he used to. Everyone went home after breakfast.
The next week and a half passed awkwardly. My dad wouldn't quite look at me in the same way, though he pretended like nothing had happened. The call I got from Laura changed that quite a bit though.
"Hey Samantha, remember the Saturday about two weeks ago when we had the sleep over?" Laura asked me.
"Yeah, what about it?" I asked her back.
"You know I almost didn't do that final dare." She said.
"Me either. But I did. We all did. Why do you mention it?" I asked.
"Well, I keep track of a lot of things, and one of those things is every detail of my menstrual cycle. That was a ovulation day for me. That means it was a day I shouldn't have sex because I might get pregnant." She stated.
"Are you telling me...?" I started to ask.
"Congratulations, you're going to be a big sister." Laura said.
I was speechless. I didn't know what to say or even how I felt.
"Hello?" she asked. "You still there?"
"Yes. I'm sorry, I just don't even know how to react to that." I said.
"Well there's more." She said.
"More?" I asked.
"Yes. You see, I also track my friends cycles. Its easy since almost all of our are synchronized. You need to go get tested. I'm calling everyone to let them know." She said.
"I see. Well thank you." I said, a feeling of dread washing over me.
"Well I'm going to let you go do what you need to go do, I still have some calls to make. I'll talk to you later this evening." She said to me. "Call me earlier if the test is positive."
"Okay." I said.
"I'll talk to you later." She said.
"Okay, goodbye." I said, then hung up the phone.
I walked out to the kitchen numbly where my dad was.
"What's Up?" He asked.
"I need to borrow ten dollars." I told him.
"What for?" He asked.
"A home pregnancy test." I replied.
"What!?" He exclaimed.
"Laura is pregnant, and our cycles are synchronized. There is a good chance I am too." I said.
He sighed and clutched the bridge of his nose with his hand. "Okay, I will go get you one. Wait here."
He left the house, and was gone for a while. He eventually came back with the test. I took it from him wordlessly and went to the bathroom with it. I took a test. It came back positive. There were five tests in the box. I took them all. Five positives. I started to cry. It was just a stupid game, how could it end like this? My dad came and knocked on the door.
"Are you okay?" He asked me through the locked door.
"No." I replied.
"Do you want to talk about it?" He asked?
"No!" I tearfully shouted through the door."
"It's okay darling. We will do whatever you want. I am here for you." He told me.
"Go away!" I shouted.
"Okay, just call me if you need me." He said.
I heard him walk away from the door. I cried for a few minutes, then I heard the phone ring. My dad answered it. I heard him speak.
"Hello? Yes she's here, who is this? She's in the bathroom right now, can I take a message? Okay I'll ask if she will talk to you." He said.
I heard him walk up to the bathroom door. He knocked twice.
"Princess, Caitlin is on the phone for you. She says its important. Should I tell her to call back later?" He asked.
I unlocked the bathroom door and stuck my hand out. He put the phone in it. I pulled the phone in with me, shutting and locking the bathroom door.
"Okay, just call me if you need me." He said. I heard him walk away.
"Hello?" I sniffed into the phone.
"It's still my turn. I dare you to keep the baby." Caitlin voice came through the phone.
"What?" I asked.
"I'm pregnant, Laura's pregnant. She told me that she already talked to you. If we're both pregnant, you probably are as well. You are upset and in the bathroom so chances are that you are, and now you have a choice. You become my slave, or you keep the baby." Caitlin stated.
"That's not funny." I said.
"Do you hear me laughing? Did I say just kidding? I got knocked up at your damn sleepover. You made me into a mother, so I'll be damned if you get away with not being one. Laura is keeping hers. I'll be talking to the rest of the girls later. I won't take no for an answer." Caitlin pushed.
"It was your fucking dare that got me into this mess." I replied angrily.
"No, it was you fucking. You could have chosen not to do it. Look, forget about all of that. I can't kill my baby. I need you to be here with me, go through it with me as my friend. Please?" She asked.
"You have Laura." I said.
"And Laura has me, and you have the both of us." She said. "This is the start of a new adventure for us, and I want to go in it together." She pleaded.
"Look, I haven't made a decision one way or another yet..." I started to say.
"Well I know how it's going to go. You're going to focus on how it was created, and talk yourself out of keeping it. Maybe you'll give it up for adoption, maybe you'll abort it. Either way you will talk yourself out of keeping it by focusing on the negative. Instead of that, why not focus on the positive? About what kind of miracle it is? On a fluke we all decide to lose our virginity together, and it happens to be on a day that we are most likely to get pregnant. And then we all end up pregnant together. Don't you see how amazing that is?"
"How is that amazing?" I asked, annoyed.
"Pregnancy from the first time isn't common, and yet we have three, on the same night, from the same guy. Laura says that each time it is less likely, so two in a row would be rare, let alone three. All from the first time. This is like, a once in five hundred lifetimes event."
I sighed. When she put it like that it did seem a little special. "Alright. I will keep it if everybody else does. We can all be pregnant together if that's what you want."
"Thank you." She said. "I'll call Laura and tell her the good news myself."
I heard the phone hang up. I put it down and took a deep breath. I picked it up and carried it back out to the living room. My dad stood up as soon as he saw me.
"Well?" He asked.
"Congratulations." I said. "You are the father of at least three new babies, and we are apparently keeping them."
I saw joy and fear dance across my dad's eyes.
"Sweet Jesus." He said.
He fell back in shock. He missed the couch and landed hard on the floor. He didn't even seem to notice.
"I'm sorry I got you into this mess." I said to him.
"It's okay princess, I forgive you." He said.
He stood back up, then wrapped his arms around me and hugged me.
Later that night we found out that violet was also pregnant, but Georgia, Tessa, and Alyssa all had negative on their test results. Alyssa missed her period a few days later, and it turned out hers was a false negative. Because I was dared last and followed through, it was my turn to make a dare. I called Laura, then Georgia. After a late night session trapping my dad into another vagina, Georgia's got herself her very own positive pregnancy test. That opened the floodgates and we all started regularly sleeping with my dad. I snuck myself into the rotation and started getting it before my dad realized who he was fucking. When he saw that I wanted the same thing my friends were getting, he got over his squeamishness and our relationship improved. Tessa was knocked up the next month. There were some conflicts with my friends parents about our 'pregnancy pact' as we all started showing, but we didn't tell them who the father was or any of the real details. We were all 18, except Violet who was 19, so it really wasn't anyone else's call but ours. Seven growing siblings, all from a stupid game. The phone was ringing. I answered it.
"I dare you to give birth without pain medication." Tessa's voice rang out. Only a couple weeks left to my due date, I considered refusing, but Laura would probably do it. This dare was probably Laura's idea, even. She was already talking about it. This game was going to be the death of me. Well I wasn't going to go through it alone.
"Well right back at you. I dare you to give birth without pain medication." I said.
"I refuse." Tessa replied. "I'll make sure everyone knows." She said, the smugness in her voice clear.
It had Laura's fingerprints all over it.
"You've got a lot longer to think about it Tes, and a lot of painful experiences to hear about. I'm sure each of us will remember to tell you every bit of pain we feel." I said, trying to intimidate her.
"You don't scare me." She replied confidently.
I smiled. I knew my next dare for her. And when to give it.
Anticipating labor was horrible, made even worse by watching the first to experience it, Violet. My new baby brother ripped Violet's tiny perineum open. Caitlin was next, and while not as severe as Violet's, hers ripped as well. Then it was my turn, and it felt even worse than it looked. Alyssa and Laura went into Labor around the same time I did, and I missed Alyssa giving birth while preoccupied with my own. Poor Laura got it the worst. Prior to her, Violet's was the longest at 4 hours. Laura was at 17 hours before she finally birthed. It only served her right.
Then two months of baby activity. Diapers and late nights for Tessa to see before it was her turn. And that's when I continued the game. In her recovery room, fresh from birthing my seventh sibling.
"Tessa, I dare you to get pregnant again..." I said.